BUSINESS-PURPOSE LOANS · NATIONWIDE
SIGN IN
ONE BRIDGE CAPITAL
Southwest Florida

How lenders decide ARV on a fix and flip

Your loan is capped by a percentage of after-repair value, so the appraiser’s number decides how much cash you bring to closing. That number is built from closed comparable sales, not from your spreadsheet.

  • ARV comes from an appraisal the lender orders, not from your estimate
  • Closed sales decide it: recent, nearby, and similar in size and finish
  • The ARV cap is only one of the caps, and the loan is the lowest of them

What ARV actually is

After-repair value is an appraiser’s opinion of what the property will be worth once the approved scope of work is finished. On a rehab file the appraiser is given your plans and your budget and asked for two numbers: what the property is worth as it sits today, and what it will be worth subject to completion of that specific scope.

Three things follow from that, and they surprise people. The lender orders the appraisal, so you do not pick the appraiser. The report is addressed to the lender, not to you. And the as-repaired number is tied to the scope in the file — if you later change the finish level, the number in the file does not follow you.

What the appraiser is allowed to use

Closed sales, not listings

Value comes from sales that already closed, commonly within the last three to six months. Active and pending listings can support a trend or bracket the top of the range, but they are not the number. A neighbor asking your ARV does not make it your ARV.

Similar size, beds and baths

Gross living area is expected to sit in a band around the subject, often within about twenty percent. Beds and baths should match. A larger comp can be used with adjustments, and those adjustments are almost always smaller than the price gap you were counting on.

Similar condition after the work

The best comp is a house renovated to roughly the level you are planning. Comps that sold in rough shape pull the number down even when your finishes are better, because the appraiser has no closed sale showing this market pays for that level.

The same market segment

School zone, subdivision, waterfront or canal access, flood zone, busy road. A sale four hundred feet away on the other side of one of those lines is a different market, and a good appraiser will not use it.

Why ARV comes back lower than your number

Five reasons account for most of it.

The scope never reached the appraiser. If the file carries a one-line budget instead of a room-by-room scope, the appraiser values a vague renovation, which is the cheapest renovation.

You are over-improving for the block. Every street has a ceiling, and quartz and a wine fridge do not break it. Spending past the ceiling is spending you do not get back.

Your comps were the top of the range. Investors naturally pick the three best sales. An appraiser brackets instead: some above, some below, and the number lands in the middle.

Added square footage is not supported or not permitted. An addition only counts if closed sales show this market pays for the larger size, and unpermitted space often gets valued at close to nothing.

Time and condition adjustments. A comp that closed nine months ago in a different market gets adjusted, and so does one that had a pool when yours does not.

The ARV cap is not the only cap

Across our lender panel, fix and flip financing commonly reaches up to 90 percent of the purchase price plus 100 percent of the rehab budget, and up to 75 percent of after-repair value. Those are maximums, and they vary by lender, by your experience and by the property.

The important part is how they work together. Underwriting runs every cap and funds the lowest one. So the appraisal barely matters when the purchase-plus-rehab cap is already the binding one — and it decides the deal when the ARV cap binds. Knowing which cap binds on your file tells you whether the appraisal is a formality or the whole ballgame.

Example scenario: which cap binds

Illustrative example. Numbers are hypothetical and not from a specific client or loan.

An investor buys at $260,000 with a $70,000 rehab budget and expects an ARV of $420,000. The appraisal comes back at $380,000.

The purchase-plus-rehab cap: 90 percent of $260,000 is $234,000, plus the full $70,000 budget, for $304,000. The ARV cap: 75 percent of $380,000 is $285,000. The lower number wins, so the loan is $285,000, of which $70,000 is held back and released in draws. That leaves $215,000 toward the purchase, and the investor brings $45,000 plus closing costs and reserves.

Had the appraisal matched the investor’s $420,000, the ARV cap would have been $315,000 and the purchase-plus-rehab cap of $304,000 would have bound instead. The loan funds $234,000 toward the purchase and the investor brings $26,000.

A $40,000 difference of opinion on ARV moved $19,000 of cash from the lender’s side of the table to the investor’s. That is why the comp set is worth an hour of your time before you make the offer.

PROCESS

How to support the number before the appraisal

STEP 01

Build the comp set yourself first

Three closed sales in the last six months, within about a mile, similar size and bed and bath count, renovated to the level you are planning. If you cannot find three, your ARV is a hope rather than a number.

STEP 02

Write the scope so it reads like a scope

Room by room, with finish levels and quantities, and roof, mechanicals and windows called out separately. This is the cheapest thing you can do to protect the as-repaired value.

STEP 03

Put the plans and the permits in the file

Anything structural, any square footage added, any change of use. Permitted work gets valued. Unpermitted work gets discounted or ignored.

STEP 04

Be reachable when the appraiser calls

Access to the property, the scope in hand, and your comps offered as information rather than as instructions. Appraisers are independent, and a useful file is the only legitimate influence you have.

STEP 05

Underwrite the deal below your expected ARV

Run the deal at a number lower than you believe and check whether it still works. If it only works at your best case, it is not a deal, it is a bet on an appraisal.

If it comes back low

Most lenders accept a reconsideration of value. It is not an argument about opinions: it is a short submission of closed sales the appraiser did not use, with a reason each one is more comparable than what was used, plus any factual corrections — wrong square footage, wrong bed count, a missed garage conversion. Opinions move nothing; a better closed comp sometimes moves a lot.

If the number holds, the arithmetic is honest about your options: bring more cash, cut scope so the purchase-plus-rehab cap binds instead, renegotiate the purchase price, or walk. The deal that hurts investors is the one where the appraisal came back low and nothing changed except optimism.

How we fit

We are a private money loan broker. We arrange business-purpose real estate financing through a panel of third-party lenders and we are not a lender ourselves. We also run a construction company, which is why the first thing we read on a rehab file is the scope: a budget that an appraiser and an underwriter can both follow is worth more to your loan amount than any argument made after the report lands.

Have a deal and a rehab budget?

Send the numbers and we will tell you which cap binds and what the cash to close looks like. Three minutes, no credit pull.

One Bridge Capital arranges business-purpose real estate financing through a panel of third-party lenders and is not a lender. Terms shown are typical ranges, vary by lender, property and borrower profile, and are not a commitment to lend. Loans are for business purposes only and are not available for owner-occupied primary residences.

QUESTIONS

Frequently asked

An appraiser the lender orders, not you and not us. The appraiser is given your scope of work and asked for the value subject to completion of that scope. Underwriting then uses that number, not your estimate, to apply the ARV cap.

Three minutes to a straight answer.

No credit pull. No cost. We tell you when it does not work.